Thinking Teaching Creating

Thoughts, Tips, Ideas, and Projects from a Creative Teacher Mama

The Leveled Classroom Library – Friend or Foe?

on August 3, 2013

Now, as you read this post, keep in mind that I’ve spent the last 9 years teaching 1st and 2nd grade.  These are grades that tend to have a huge span between the most and least capable readers in your class, and even more so if you teach gifted kids.  The past few years, I’ve taught first grade, and my class tended to start the year ranging from a DRA level 6 all the way through a DRA level 38.  As a result, my classroom library needed to have books that were appropriate for the kids reading at an end of kindergarten/beginning of first grade level all the way up through those who would be reading at a fourth grade level by the end of the year.

Let’s take a minute, and put yourself into the shoes of a student who is told they may only take books that are certain levels, or even that they may only read the books their teacher actually hands them to read.  Imagine you’ve gotten onto your computer to look through Pinterest.  You see beautiful photos of recipes you want to try, crafts you want to make, and clothes you wish filled your closet.  Every time you want to find out more about one, you click on it.  Sometimes clicking the photo sends you to the site to find out how to make it or where to buy it.  Other times, you get messages like, “That’s too hard for you!” or “That craft is too easy, you did that last year.” Or, the most discouraging of all, “You’ll never afford that dress on a teacher’s salary, hit up your local Goodwill instead!”  That would pretty much suck, wouldn’t it?  That’s exactly what we’re doing to our students when we put interesting books in front of them, but tell them they can only choose from a certain level range preventing books from being too easy or too hard.

Many of my books do have stickers on the spine indicating the approximate level (I have a poster that shows the colors to mean easy, easy-medium, medium, medium-hard, and hard), and I do tell students the color that they are likely to read with the most success.  However, I almost never tell students that they are only allowed to choose books with certain color stickers.  The exception to that are students who consistently choose books that are way too hard for them, and then become frustrated because they can’t read them.  These kids typically end up spending more time switching books than they do actually reading them.  For those few students, I talk to them about how their choices of books only seem to be frustrating them, and that it’s resulting in their reading time not being spent reading.  So, they end up with a limit of how difficult the books they choose can be, but I only set that limit for a week or two before I watch to see if they’re able to make better choices on their own again.

Think about that really cool book you have on dinosaurs that’s written at a 4th grade reading level.  It has lots of pictures, doesn’t it?  Wouldn’t it be awful to deprive the kid reading at a first grade level who is obsessed with dinosaurs the opportunity to look through that book because it’s too hard?  No, he won’t be able to read all the words, or even most of them.  But, if a student is motivated to read, they’ll try that much harder.  The little girl who reads at a second grade level but grabbed the fattest Harry Potter book on the shelf because it’s what her big sister is reading won’t understand most of what she’s reading, but she’s motivated to read.  I’ve had students whose parents shared with me that their child really disliked reading, and typically those are the same children who would be at the bottom of the class if they were ranked by reading level.  Have you read the books that are DRA 6-10?  They are BORING and repetitive!  There’s very little to the stories, and I wouldn’t like reading if that’s all I were allowed to read either!  But, reading appropriately leveled books for instruction and being allowed to explore the wide world of books that have more substance to their stories on their own is often enough motivation to make a student become a reader.

The standards say my job is to teach students to read to at least a certain reading level and to make them capable of answering certain types of questions and thinking about books in certain ways.  Ultimately though, my job is to teach children how to love stories and learn from what they read.  Leveled readers, especially at the lower levels, do not do a great job of creating a love of reading.


2 responses to “The Leveled Classroom Library – Friend or Foe?

  1. Great post! Kids have to really want to read to succeed; and telling them that they can only pick certain books has got to be frustrating.

  2. rebekah1986 says:

    Reblogged this on rebekahfaithblog and commented:
    to level and how?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: